Siesta Key is known for its stunning beaches and energetic environment, but it also has a range of lovely eateries that will satisfy any food lover’s demands. Siesta Key has something for everyone, whether looking for fresh seafood, exotic cuisine, or delicious American favorites.
Are you looking for some of the most delectable spots on Siesta Key? Check out these must-try spots while you’re staying in one of our Siesta Key vacation rentals!
Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood
Proudly serving the best hand-selected cuts from the most prominent ranches, such as Snake River Farms, Revier Cattle Company, and Niman Ranch, Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood is a delicious spot you won’t want to miss!
On their menu, you’ll find fantastic dishes made with fresh ingredients and local flavors. Their steaks and chops feature mouthwatering steaks aged 40 days to maximize flavor and tenderness and cooed to your liking, and you can finish any steak with a housemade sauce like their Cognac mushroom sauce or a fresh truffle bearnaise. Under entrees, you’ll find signature dishes like their Apple Balsamic Glazed Scottish Salmon and a 24-hour Sous Vide Lamb Shank.
Don’t forget about their extensive wine menu, where you’ll find the perfect pairing to any dish.
The Cottage
Tucked away in Siesta Key Village, The Cottage is a local favorite for its flavorful tapas and craft cocktails. This quaint eatery features tasteful seaside décor together with a laid-back beach ambiance. The menu offers all your favorite American classics with a bit of local flare.
Try a mouthwatering sandwich like their Billionaire Burger, a succulent burger made to order and topped with sharp cheddar, housemade bacon-onion jam, and truffle aioli on a toasted brioche bun. Or sample having a fun evening sampling chef-created tapas, like their tuna ceviche, grilled shrimp causa, or their famous Cottage crab cakes.
Don’t forget to add the perfect drink to your meal with something from their bar menu. Try something spicy and tropical like the jalapeno watermelon margarite or something sweet and floral like the lemon & lavender. Not feeling like an alcoholic drink? Order one of their delightful mocktails, and get all the love with non of the hangover! They also offer an impressive list of reds, whites, bottled and canned beers, as well as a rotation of local brews on tap! This is definitely a hot spot to check out during your stay in on of our Siesta Key Florida vacation rentals.
Island House Tap & Grill
The bustling restaurant Island House Tap & Grill on Siesta Key is well-known for its welcoming staff and energetic ambiance. Their menu features a variety of substantial American cuisine with a tropical twist. There is something for every palate, from succulent burgers and savory wings to fresh seafood and delectable sandwiches.
Take notice of their renowned Fish Tacos or trademark Island Nachos. The restaurant also offers craft beers, inventive cocktails, and refreshing drinks. Island House Tap & Grill offers a comfortable and welcoming setting for a leisurely meal or enjoyable evening out on Siesta Key!
Siesta Key Oyster Bar
A great place to visit while staying in one of our Siesta Key vacation rentals is The Siesta Key Oyster Bar, often known as SKOB. This is a well-known seafood spot on Siesta Key. This bustling oyster bar has a laid-back ambiance and is popular with residents and tourists. Fresh oysters are SKOB’s specialty; they can be ordered raw on the half-shell or steamed with mouthwatering toppings.
Not a fan of oysters? No stress! You’ll find a wide range of seafood dishes, including delectable shrimp, crab cakes, fish tacos, and so much more. From their broad drink menu, choose an excellent beer or a tropical cocktail to go with your meal. Siesta Key Oyster Bar is a must-go for seafood lovers, whether you’re looking for great oysters or a seafood feast.
Plan Your Visit
Plan your vacation in one of the best vacation rentals, Siesta Key offers, by booking your stay with Your Next Destination Paradise! Our rentals are equipped with everything you need during your stay and are the perfect place to relax and unwind while you’re here. View all our rentals and book your stay today!
Cafe Gabbiano
Cafe Gabbiano is a beautiful Italian restaurant that offers a unique dining experience. It is located right in the center of Siesta Key. The restaurant has a cozy, welcoming atmosphere that embodies the kindness and charm of Italy. Cafe Gabbiano enjoys offering delicious and authentic Italian food, from traditional pasta dishes to mouthwatering seafood delicacies.
Enjoy their delicious homemade pasta, or take in the aromas of their wood-fired pizzas. Servers can help you select the perfect wine from their vast wine cellar to complement your meal. With every mouthwatering bite, Cafe Gabbiano promises to take your taste buds to Italy, whether looking for a romantic evening or a wonderful lunch.
The Old Salty Dog
The Old Salty Dog, a fixture on Siesta Key, perfectly captures the spirit of a traditional coastal restaurant. This laid-back eatery offers a typical Florida eating experience just steps from the sand. It’s a must-try because of its famous Salty Dog hot dog, topped with sauerkraut and special seasonings.
Fish and chips, shrimp baskets, and seafood platters are just a few of the fresh seafood selections on the menu. Make your way out to the patio so you can enjoy the beautiful Gulf Coast weather while you dine. The Old Salty Dog is popular among locals and visitors because of its lively environment, welcoming staff, and reasonable costs. Visit The Old Salty Dog on Siesta Key for a beautiful dining experience.
Another Broken Egg Cafe
Another Broken Egg Cafe is one of the top breakfast and brunch restaurants in Siesta Key. This quaint cafe provides a great eating experience with its warm and welcoming ambiance. Their menu offers a selection of delectable breakfast dishes with unique twists.
There is something for every palate, from fluffy omelets and flavorful benedicts to luscious pancakes and fresh salads. Take advantage of their famous Lobster & Brie Omelet or the French Toast Cinnamon Rolls. Another Broken Egg Cafe is ideal for a filling breakfast in Siesta Key, with warm hospitality and a welcoming atmosphere.
Where to Stay in Siesta Key
Find the perfect vacation rentals in Siesta Key for your stay with Destination Paradise! Our Siesta Key rentals are equipped with everything you need for the perfect getaway and put you close to all the best Siesta Key restaurants.
Whether you’re looking for a spacious beachfront Siesta Key vacation rental that your whole family will love or a cozy condo for a romantic getaway with someone special, we have the perfect spot for you! Find your Siesta Key home away from home and start planning your vacation in paradise today!
